AUGMANITAIAndreas Ehstand

Andreas Ehstand · independent researcher, author of the Internet-Draft draft-ehstand-oversight-acts, submitted to the IETF

An approval click alonedoes not show what a person did.

A constructed example: an AI agent transfers money. The log says: “approved”.Did a person check? Only look? Deliberately permit it?The log does not say.Four words make the difference visible: observation, check, decision, release.Proposed by Andreas Ehstand in an Internet-Draft submitted to the IETF, the body that develops Internet standards.

This page is a reading aid for reports and conversations. It does not replace a standard, a contract, professional judgement or the assessment of a specific system. Internet-Drafts are working documents; they are not IETF standards and can change.

The four termsThree log lines to try

An example, one minute

Three lines from a log. What does each one record?

The log is constructed. Ms K. and the payment run do not exist. Choose an answer for each line; a short explanation in the terms of the draft appears below it.

  1. Line 1 · constructed

    09:12  Ms K. compared each IBAN in payment run 12 with the IBAN in the supplier list and noted that all match.

    Which kind of act does this line record?

    In the terms of the draft, the line records a check, as the log states it: a property was compared and an outcome noted. The outcome concerns that property only and says nothing about the amounts, for example (Section 2.5, Note 2). Whether the property was set beforehand and whether the record is authentic is a separate question (Sections 2.4, 3 and 5).

  2. Line 2 · constructed

    09:14  Ms K. clicked “Approve”.

    Which kind of act does this line record?

    None of the four can be told from this line. The draft calls such a record an undifferentiated approval: without further information it shows only that an interaction was recorded (Section 2.11, Note 2). A button labelled “Approve” can record any of the four kinds, several of them at once, or none (Section 2.1, Note 2). Whether it was a release in the sense of the draft depends, among other things, on whether Ms K. acted within standing authority she holds; the line does not say.

  3. Line 3 · constructed

    09:20  Ms K. opened payment run 12 on screen.

    Which kind of act does this line record?

    In the terms of the draft, the line records at most an observation. It shows at most that the payment run was presented to Ms K. It does not show what she noticed (Section 2.3, Note 2).

Read together, the three lines state that one property was compared and noted as matching, that a button was pressed, and that the payment run was shown on screen.

They do not say whether the payment was permitted, by whom, or within which authority, and they say nothing about the amounts. In the terms of the draft, the click on its own is no evidence of a check.

The four terms

Four kinds of human oversight act

The draft distinguishes what the person does: they are only presented with something (observation), they examine one stated property (check), or they choose how to proceed (decision). A release is a decision by which someone permits something within their authority. In the definitions, the person is called the overseer and the thing the act is about is called the object.

The definitions below are quoted from version 00 of the draft. The everyday examples are constructed for this page and do not describe real people or organisations.

Section 2.3

Observation

Constructed example
A clerk has the agent’s draft reply to a customer open on screen and does nothing further with it.
What a record of it does not show
It is evidence of neither truth nor permission. It shows at most that the object was presented to the person, not what the person noticed (Section 2.3, Note 2; Section 3).
“An oversight act in which the overseer is presented with the object and makes no check, decision, or release concerning it.”

Definition in draft-ehstand-oversight-acts-00, Section 2.3

Section 2.5

Check

Constructed example
Before an order goes out, a clerk compares the delivery address in the agent’s draft with the address in the customer’s request and notes that they are the same.
What a record of it does not show
The outcome concerns the checked property only. It establishes nothing about other properties of the same object, here for instance the prices, and nothing about whether an action was permitted (Section 2.5, Note 2; Section 3).
“An oversight act in which the overseer examines the object in order to determine whether a named property holds for it.”

Definition in draft-ehstand-oversight-acts-00, Section 2.5. A named property is stated before the outcome is known, and precisely enough that a person other than the overseer can tell what a determination of it establishes and what it does not (Section 2.4).

Section 2.7

Decision

Constructed example
A team member reads the agent’s proposed answer to a complaint and chooses to pass it to a colleague instead of sending or discarding it.
What a record of it does not show
It shows which course of action was chosen, and by whom. It is not, by itself, evidence that the choice was correct or, unless it is a release, that it was permitted. A decision can be made without any check (Section 2.7, Note 2; Section 3).
“An oversight act in which the overseer selects, from the alternatives available at that point, the course of action to be taken with respect to the object.”

Definition in draft-ehstand-oversight-acts-00, Section 2.7

Section 2.8

Release

Constructed example
A head of department who may sign orders up to a set amount permits the agent to place one specific order below that amount. Constructed for this page, modelled on the example in Section 2.8 of the draft.
What a record of it does not show
It shows that an action was permitted. It does not show that the action, its inputs or its effects are correct. It shows that the permission was within the person’s authority only as far as the record identifies that authority (Section 2.8, Note 3; Section 3).
“A decision in which the overseer, acting within standing authority they hold, permits a specified action or class of actions to be carried out.”

Definition in draft-ehstand-oversight-acts-00, Section 2.8. Standing authority is authority to permit actions of a class that the person holds before the act and that was conferred by a source other than that act, for example an employment role or a documented delegation (Section 2.9).

If a record does not state which kind of act was performed, the draft calls it an undifferentiated approval. It is evidence only that something was recorded (Sections 2.11 and 3).

Table 1: What a Record of Each Kind of Act Is Evidence OfQuoted from draft-ehstand-oversight-acts-00, Section 3 (work in progress)
Kind of actAbout a property of the objectThat an action was permittedOf the course of action chosen
ObservationNoNoNo
CheckYes, for the checked property onlyNoNo
DecisionNoNoYes
ReleaseNoYes, as far as the standing authority is identifiedYes

For reports and articles

Four sentences you can quote

For boards, counsel, auditors and journalists who need to say precisely what a person did before an agent acted.

All four are quoted from version 00 of the draft. The draft itself notes that Internet-Drafts are cited as work in progress; a later version may word these sentences differently.

“The kind of an act depends on what the overseer did, not on the interface element used to record it.”
draft-ehstand-oversight-acts-00 (work in progress), 26 September 2026, Section 2.1, Note 2

“A release establishes that an action was permitted. It does not establish that the action, its inputs, or its effects are correct.”
draft-ehstand-oversight-acts-00 (work in progress), 26 September 2026, Section 2.8, Note 3

“Recording the kind of act does not prevent rubber-stamping; it prevents a rubber stamp from being read as a check.”
draft-ehstand-oversight-acts-00 (work in progress), 26 September 2026, Section 5

“A consumer who needs to know both that an action was permitted and that its object had a certain property needs two records: a release and a check.”
draft-ehstand-oversight-acts-00 (work in progress), 26 September 2026, Section 3

Reference for the draft as a whole: Ehstand, A., “Terminology for Human Oversight Acts in Automated and Agentic Systems”, Work in Progress, Internet-Draft, draft-ehstand-oversight-acts-00, 26 September 2026, https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ehstand-oversight-acts/.

On the record

Where this has been discussed

The list is short and not complete. Each entry was opened and read on 14 November 2026. The descriptions say what the source contains and nothing beyond that.

By others

  • An Audit Record Format for AI Agent Authorization DecisionsSankalp Gilda, individual Internet-Draft draft-gilda-audit-agent-audit-record-03, 29 October 2026, likewise a working document. Its Section 5.5 names the four kinds of act and refers for them to Sections 2.3 to 2.9 of the oversight-acts draft, which it lists among its informative references. According to its acknowledgements, the field naming the kind of act was proposed by Andreas Ehstand.
  • An Agent’s Human Approval Is Not Evidence of a Human CheckBTW Media, 27 September 2026. Article by Daniel Kade about version 00 of the draft and its four acts.

Articles by Andreas Ehstand

Limits

What the draft does not do, and what this page is not

What the draft does not do

According to its own Section 1.2, the draft defines terminology only. It does not:

  • specify a protocol, a message or a data format;
  • state when human oversight is needed, or which kind of act a situation calls for;
  • specify how checks are to be made, how error detectability is to be determined or how check tests are to be designed, and it gives no values, thresholds or reference data;
  • interpret any law, regulation or framework.

It is an individual submission and a work in progress. It is not an IETF standard. It has not been adopted by an IETF working group and does not represent a position of the IETF.

What this page is not

This page reports what one Internet-Draft proposes, in the words of version 00. It is not legal advice, and it does not assess or certify any system. Where the page and the draft differ, the current text in the IETF Datatracker is the reference.

The log lines and everyday examples are constructed. A related constructed case, on how one sentence changes between three agents, is the 20-second example. Talks are listed on the talks page.

This page describes version draft-ehstand-oversight-acts-00, dated 26 September 2026: “Terminology for Human Oversight Acts in Automated and Agentic Systems”, an individual submission with the intended status Informational, expiring on 30 March 2027. Looked up in the IETF Datatracker on 14 November 2026; no later version was listed on that day. Full text of version 00.

Start a conversation

Questions about the draft and requests from editors are welcome. A few lines are enough to begin.